Head Office:
5th Floor Maddox House, 1 Maddox Street, Mayfair, London, W1S 2PZ

How do fresh claims and further submissions work in asylum cases?

If a person has claimed asylum in the UK and that asylum claim is refused by the Home Office, a person has a right of appeal within the UK, initially to the First-Tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) and subsequently, if there is an error of law in the first judge’s decision, to the Upper Tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). It may be that an appellant has a further right of appeal to the Court of Appeal or in very rare cases the Supreme Court.  In order to obtain a hearing in any of the courts other than the First-Tier Tribunal, an appellant must obtain permission to appeal. If they do not obtain permission to appeal, then they will become ‘appeal rights exhausted’.

What happens if my appeal rights are exhausted?

It is not unusual for a person to remain in the UK after becoming appeal rights exhausted. They will usually have no access to any supporting benefits any longer; they will also have no access to the rental market, the employment market, and so on. This is known as the ‘hostile environment’ (or the rebranded ‘compliant environment’).

Failed asylum-seekers have the right to make further submissions to the Home Office at any point after their asylum claim was refused and they are appeal rights exhausted. There are many reasons why a person may make further submissions. If the failed asylum seeker was politically active in their home country, it might be the case that they have been politically active in the UK. This is known as a sur-place claim.

Submitting new evidence in asylum cases

In other cases, new evidence becomes available that proves that the Home Office and judges involved in deciding their case were wrong. This might be physical evidence such as an arrest warrant, or a political membership card from their own country, or could be evidence of a witness, for example, someone that the failed asylum seeker knew in their home country. In some cases, the country situation has changed so dramatically since that failed asylum seeker was refused it would now be accepted that they could not return to that country.

If there is new evidence, the failed asylum seeker can travel to Liverpool to submit further submissions to the Home Office. Those submissions will amount to a ‘fresh claim’ if they are significantly different from the material that was previously considered by the Home Office and the tribunal. The Home Office will only consider those submissions to be significantly different, if, firstly, they have not already been considered, meaning that this is new information or new evidence that wasn’t before the Home Office or the tribunal and that taken with that previously considered material, the further submissions create a realistic prospect of success.

The 3 possible outcomes

There are three possible outcomes to putting in further submissions. Firstly, the applicant can be granted refugee status. Secondly, the applicant can be refused refugee status; however, the Home Office is satisfied that the further submissions amount to a fresh claim and therefore, there is right of appeal to the tribunal. Finally, the further submissions could be refused by the Home Office, and they could also conclude that there is no realistic prospect of success and therefore certify the claim, meaning that there is no right of appeal to the tribunal. The only challenge to the third outcome would be to review that refusal as being unreasonable or unlawful judicially. This may result in the Home Office reconsidering whether to treat the submissions as a fresh claim and ultimately refusing without certifying, so as to allow the applicant a right of appeal to the tribunal.

You can reach our office at: 020 7118 4546 or email at: info@westkin.com

Immigration Cases

What we're saying

@westkinlaw

IMMIGRATION BLOG

Read All

  • Why Boris is attacking Judicial Reviews – Part 2

    Have you read part 1? Click here to read part 1. The “1%” lie! So, you may be getting a sense of why the government ...

    Read More

  • Why Boris is attacking Judicial Reviews- Part 1

    What is a Judicial Review?  Judicial review is a means by which a person, often represented by lawyers, challenges a decision of the state where ...

    Read More

  • How does the Home Office suspend employers’ licences?

    From practice, it appears that the UK government often target licence holders in rounds. I.e. there seems to be certain times where the Home Office ...

    Read More

  • Did Labour’s immigration policy lose them the election?

    On 16th February, deputy leader candidate for the Labour party, Angela Rayner, sat down with BBC journalist Andrew Marr for an interview during which he ...

    Read More

  • How to successfully apply for a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS)

    This blog gives an overview of CoS’ when to use a restricted CoS, when to use an unrestricted, how to apply for each type of ...

    Read More