Head Office:
5th Floor Maddox House, 1 Maddox Street, Mayfair, London, W1S 2PZ

A love letter to Lady Hale

Lady Hale has long been revered by law students, particularly female law students, so it was with some delight that I watched her catapulted into the limelight after her typically well-reasoned and clear judgement, in the case of the prorogation of Parliament. I have enjoyed reading numerous articles about lady Hale’s background and watching interviews with her on YouTube where she so effortlessly navigates that treacherous ground between ‘things you definitely cannot say’ and ‘saying nothing of any interest’.  Lady Hale’s comments on the benefits of being a woman at Oxford University in a male-dominated environment are particularly tickling.

What I’ve noticed from those interviews, is that despite having made her career as a judge and despite some of the things being said to her being absolutely outrageous, there never seems to be any flicker of disbelief or judgement in her eyes. Just a well-reasoned response and a point of view capable of change. It is this ability to change her mind that makes me think it’s not the right time for retirement for this Lady.

My first encounter

I once attended a talk with Lady Hale, or Baroness Hale, as she was then called at the College of Law. Lady Hale attended with another female judge to talk about feminism and the law. The other female judge, whose name I forget and given what follows, it is probably for the best, recounted a tale, where, as head of Chambers, she recruited a number of bright young female pupils, who later gained tenancy at Chambers and, after several years later, more or less the same time, all left to have children.  The female judge stated that the next time she recruited pupils, she would ensure that there was a mix of genders and recruited less able men over their female adversaries. Again, it was without judgement that Lady Hale explained that this is what we were up against, before also saying that of course, this was totally illegal and that as good female lawyers we would be expected to take appropriate action.

The legacy of Hale

Apart from Lady Hale’s immaculate manner, it is her ability to state her opinion and for all around her to say ‘well, yes, obviously’. If you look at the changes that lady Hale has been responsible for throughout her career, not just as a judge, they appear radical. But they are not radical changes; they are obvious changes. Lady Hale has been a driving force behind the Children’s Act, putting children’s interests first and other interests second. In immigration law, lady Hale’s leading judgement in  ZH (Tanzania) v SSHD [2011] UKSC 4 was that the European Convention on Human Rights should not be interpreted in a vacuum, but should be interpreted in harmony with general principles of international law, namely the United Nation’s Convention of the Rights of the Child 1989. This is hardly radical when putting like that, but that is Lady Hale’s knack. An ability to state the obvious without anyone having realised it was obvious before it was stated by her. Perhaps this is because Lady Hale is a woman and has been a ‘first’ numerous times throughout her career. Perhaps it is because hers is the first female voice we have heard at many levels. I suspect though, it’s the quality of that voice, rather than just the gender of that voice. I guess we will have to see in the coming month. Please step up Lady Black and Lady Arden!

Reach our immigration lawyers by calling: 020 7118 4546 or email at: info@westkin.com

Immigration Cases

What we're saying

@westkinlaw

IMMIGRATION BLOG

Read All

  • Why Boris is attacking Judicial Reviews – Part 2

    Have you read part 1? Click here to read part 1. The “1%” lie! So, you may be getting a sense of why the government ...

    Read More

  • Why Boris is attacking Judicial Reviews- Part 1

    What is a Judicial Review?  Judicial review is a means by which a person, often represented by lawyers, challenges a decision of the state where ...

    Read More

  • How does the Home Office suspend employers’ licences?

    From practice, it appears that the UK government often target licence holders in rounds. I.e. there seems to be certain times where the Home Office ...

    Read More

  • Did Labour’s immigration policy lose them the election?

    On 16th February, deputy leader candidate for the Labour party, Angela Rayner, sat down with BBC journalist Andrew Marr for an interview during which he ...

    Read More

  • How to successfully apply for a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS)

    This blog gives an overview of CoS’ when to use a restricted CoS, when to use an unrestricted, how to apply for each type of ...

    Read More